Pennsylvania Attorney for Car Crashes Caused by Defective Guardrails

Table of Contents

    The consequences and injuries that can be potentially inflicted by a high-speed car, truck or SUV collision are often severe. These accidents inflict such severe injuries because a moving vehicle that collides with another object – regardless of whether a vehicle or stationary object —  a great deal of forces act upon the vehicle and its occupants. This is why many types of life-saving technology, such as crumple zones and airbags, focus on absorbing the violent forces in an accident so that the injuries to the vehicle occupants are less severe.

    Aside from the safety technologies found in the vehicles themselves, guardrails commonly found alongside highways throughout Pennsylvania and the nation, also play a vital role in reducing highway accident injuries.

    However, when the guardrails that are supposed to protect motorist are defective, injuries can be made worse or new injuries can be caused. The personal injury attorneys of The Reiff Law Firm have fought for individuals injured by defective products for more than 34 years.

    How Do Guardrails Reduce Fatalities and Injury Severity?

    Guardrails are an essential component of highway safety. Properly installed and constructed guardrails can reduce injuries and save lives in a number of ways. To begin with, guardrails are designed to give way when stopping a vehicle. The guardrail is designed to crumple or compress for a similar reason the cars have crumple zones. That is, the design allows for the guardrail or vehicle to crumple so the violent forces from the collision are distributed over time. By distributing the forces over a greater time period, the collision will be less severe to vehicle occupants and it should result in less severe injuries.

    Aside from the impact absorbing properties of a guardrail, a guardrail also prevents the vehicle from leaving the roadway. This can mean that a guardrail can stop an out-of-control vehicle from leaving the roadway, crossing the median, and passing into oncoming traffic where a head-on collision is likely. Furthermore, a guardrail can prevent the vehicle from running off the roadway and striking an object, such as a tree, that is less likely to give way and absorb the impact safely. Finally, guardrails can prevent motorists from careening off of the roadway and into a ditch or into another roadside hazard.

    What’s The Problem With ET-Plus Guardrails?

    At least 9 personal injury suits have already been filed due to injuries allegedly suffered because of defective ET-Plus guardrail end terminals. Severe injuries have included:

    • Rebecca Dryer of Pennsylvania was severely injured when her right leg was amputated. Ms. Dryer’s vehicle was “speared” or “impaled” by an ET-Plus guardrail end terminal that failed to crumple and absorb the impact.
    • Sabrina Carrier, from Tennessee, was fatally injured after being impaled in the in the stomach by a guardrail end terminal.
    • Charles Pike of Florida also had to have his leg amputated after colliding with an end terminal in his pick-up truck.

    According to internal documents obtained by ABC News these injuries were caused by a simple cost-saving, but unauthorized, change to the design by Trinity Industries. According to these documents Trinity engineers reduced each end terminal by about an inch in size. This change saved the company about $2 per a unit. It is estimated that over the course of a year, the company would net about an additional $50,000 in profits. The changes made to the guardrail end terminal design result in the guardrails no longer functioning properly and absorbing the violent forces in a crash. Rather, the changes have caused the end terminals to act like a spear. With the new design, the guardrails show a much higher rate of failing to crumple. In fact, a study commissioned by The Safety Institute showed that the new ET-Plus guardrails did not perform as well as the previous design.  The study determined that the new design was 1.36 times more likely to produce a severe injury and 2.86 times more likely to produce a fatality.  Drivers and vehicle occupants are being impaled by the guardrail that is supposed to protect them.

    27 States Have Already Banned Defective Guardrail

    In a False Claims Act lawsuit brought against Trinity Industries, U.S. ex rel. Joshua Harman v. Trinity Industries Inc., a jury found Trinity liable for fraud due to the undisclosed changes made to the guardrails. Because the action was brought under a fraud statute, a trebled award was available. The jury found the company liable for fraud and awarded $525 million in damages which will be split between the whistle-blower and the US government. Furthermore, during the trial proceedings, it was disclosed that Trinity may have also misled a number of states about changes to and the safety of the product. Court records have indicated that, as early as 2006, Trinity representatives had sent a letter to officials in Vermont assuring them that the guardrails delivered were identical to the ones tested and approved in 2005.

    These revelations have resulted in a number of states moving to ban or enact moratoriums on the further installation of Trinity ET-Plus guardrail end units. States that have already taken action include:

    • Nevada
    • Missouri
    • Massachusetts
    • Virginia
    • Oregon
    • Mississippi
    • Vermont
    • Hawaii
    • Colorado
    • New Hampshire
    • Delaware
    • Pennsylvania

    If you have already been severely injured due to a defective guardrail, contact the personal injury and defective product attorneys of The Reiff Law Firm today by calling (215) 709-6940. We offer free and confidential initial consultations.

    personal injury lawyer

    ...without them I would have been lost.

    I can’t say enough great things about the Attorneys at the Reiff Law Firm. They made me feel at ease when I was going through a very difficult time in my life. Never being in a situation like this I was so unsure of where to start and how to go about the process. Justin gave me options where I thought I had none and explained everything in a way that I could understand. Justin and the team helped me arrange all of the treatment and therapy that I needed, without them I would have been lost. My attorney John went to bat for me like no one else could have, his knowledge and professionalism is unmatched. If anyone is ever in need of a team of attorneys the Reiff Law Firm is my ONLY recommendation.

    personal injury lawyer

    ...what started as a small settlement ended $100, 000 more than expected.

    I greatly appreciate the care and compassion the Reiff Law Firm has given to my family at a very difficult time. They left no stone unturned in their investigation and what started as a small settlement ended $100, 000 more than expected. They did not give up and treated us like family.

    personal injury lawyer

    I’m very comfortable to say there’s no better in the city.

    Before meeting with Jeffrey Reiff and Bob Szostak from the Reiff law firm I’ve consulted with a few other injury attorneys in the Philadelphia region. Difference was, these guys know their stuff! I was absolutely blown away by how compassionate and welcome this law firm makes you feel. Once signed with them I never went a single week without staying in the loop with the progress and updates these guys have on your case. Working with them for some time turned what was an injury case, into a family! From calls and meetings, to just calling in to say “hi how’s everything going” I’ve never felt like a beat was skipped. I’d recommended the Reiff law firm 100%! I’m very comfortable to say there’s no better in the city. The awards they’ve earned over the years speaks for itself! I can never thank the Reiff law firm and Bob Szostak enough for everything they’ve done, their professionalism, compassion and all of their knowledge and experience! Highly rated! Best in the city! I look forward continuing our relationship in the future. Thanks again My Reiff family!

    personal injury lawyer

    ...I want to say that the Reiff Law Firm changed my entire life with handling of my legal case.

    As a former client, I want to say that the Reiff Law Firm changed my entire life with handling of my legal case. I was in a very serious automobile accident with severe injuries to neck and back areas. I contacted the law firm and asked what to do with the medical bills and how do I get the correct representation against the individual who rear-ended my car. In short, the firm took complete control of the case contacting my insurance company and asking for all the medical bills and legal matters be sent directly to them. I was able to get treatment from my doctor without worrying about the legal stuff. Furthermore, two years later the case was settled for a substantial amount of money. My life was much better due to the firm handling of my case. My attorneys at Reiff Law Firm are absolutely the best and I have recommended to my family friends. Thanks Reiff Law Firm.

    personal injury lawyer

    What started out as a time for me that included a lot of doubt, questions and hopelessness has turned into one of a hopeful future.

    I highly recommend the team at the Reiff Law Firm. Both Jeff and Robert were there to guide me through a very difficult time. What started out as a time for me that included a lot of doubt, questions and hopelessness has turned into one of a hopeful future. The team at the Reiff Law Firm made me feel at ease and I had no doubts trusting them with various concerns. They kept me informed every step of the way without making me feel overwhelmed or anxious. Don't hesitate to contact them for your legal needs - especially if you want a team that has the utmost concern and compassion for their clients.

    personal injury lawyer


    I was referred to the Reiff Law Firm by a friend who had previously been a client of the firm. My friend told me that the Reiff Firm had done an incredible job handling his case and treated him like family. My friend's recommendation was spot on. I am going to miss them now that my case is over. Attorney Reiff and Attorney Toczydlowski are excellent attorneys. They really care. They got me an INCREDIBLE RESULT. Most importantly they were there for me during some extremely dark and difficult times in my life. I highly recommend the Reiff Law Firm to anyone seeking the very best legal representation for injuries they suffered in an accident.

    Verdicts & Settlements

    $13 Million

    Auto Defect/Product Liability

    Read More
    $8 Million

    Auto Defect/Product Liability

    Read More

    Our Offices

    1500 John F. Kennedy Blvd #501
    Philadelphia, PA 19102
    Get Directions

    Get a Free Case Review

    "*" indicates required fields

    This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.